Home - Outside Gear

Replacing a water heater element is a manageable DIY project requiring basic tools and about 1-2 hours of work. Signs of a failing element include insufficient hot water, unusual noises, and tripped circuit breakers. The process involves shutting off power, draining the tank, removing the old element, and installing a new one with proper sealing. With elements costing $15-$50 and professional installation running $150-$300, DIY replacement can save significant money while restoring hot water efficiency. How Do You Know When a Water Heater Element Needs Replacement? Several clear signs indicate your water heater element may need replacement: Not enough hot water or water not getting hot enough Hot water that runs out faster than normal Unusual popping, crackling, or rumbling sounds from the tank Circuit breaker for the water heater repeatedly tripping Increasing electric bills without changes in usage patterns Visible corrosion, blistering, or breakage on the element (if inspected) Water heater taking longer than usual to recover after use Hot water has a metallic smell or rusty appearance Inconsistent water temperature during showers or other use Water heater is working but delivering lukewarm water at maximum setting These symptoms may also indicate other water heater problems, so testing the element with a multimeter is recommended for confirmation. What Tools Do You Need to Replace a Hot Water Heater Element? Gathering the proper tools before starting makes the replacement process much smoother: Element wrench (socket tool specifically for water heater elements) Voltage tester (non-contact type for safety verification) Garden hose (for draining the tank) Bucket (for catching residual water) Adjustable wrench or socket set Screwdriver (flathead and Phillips) Teflon tape or pipe thread compound New heating element (matching voltage and wattage) New rubber gasket (if not included with element) Wire brush (for cleaning threads and connections) Shop towels or rags (for cleanup) Multimeter (for testing element functionality) Pipe wrench (may be needed for stubborn elements) Plumber's grease (optional, for gasket) Having all materials ready prevents mid-project interruptions and reduces the time your water heater remains out of service. Is Replacing a Water Heater Element a DIY Job? Replacing a water heater element is a moderately easy DIY job suitable for homeowners with basic hand tool experience. The project requires minimal technical knowledge but demands careful attention to electrical safety procedures. Most homeowners can complete the replacement in 1-2 hours without specialized training or expensive tools. Key considerations for DIY success include: Comfort working with electricity and water systems Physical ability to access the water heater and operate the necessary tools Willingness to follow safety protocols precisely Basic understanding of home electrical systems Situations where professional help is recommended: Water heater is still under warranty (DIY may void coverage) Signs of multiple issues beyond just element failure Lack of confidence in electrical safety procedures Water heater located in a difficult-to-access location Presence of unusual wiring or modified electrical connections The financial savings of DIY replacement are substantial – typically $100-250 compared to professional service. How to Safely Replace a Hot Water Heater Element Turn off power to the water heater at the circuit breaker and verify with a voltage tester that power is disconnected. Turn off the cold water supply valve to the water heater. Open a hot water faucet somewhere in your house to relieve pressure in the system. Connect a garden hose to the drain valve at the bottom of the tank. Place the other end of the hose in a drain or outside where draining hot water won't cause damage. Open the drain valve and allow water to drain until the level is below the element (or completely if desired). Remove the access panel and insulation covering the element. Disconnect the wires from the element, noting their positions for reinstallation. Use an element wrench to unscrew the old element counterclockwise. Clean the element opening with a rag to remove any debris or sediment. Install the new element with a new gasket, applying Teflon tape to the threads if needed. Tighten the new element with the element wrench until snug, but avoid overtightening. Reconnect the wires to the same terminals they were removed from. Close the drain valve and remove the garden hose. Turn on the cold water supply and allow the tank to fill completely. Open hot water faucets throughout the house until water flows steadily, then close them. Check for leaks around the new element. Replace the insulation and access panel. Turn the power back on at the circuit breaker only after confirming the tank is full. How to Turn Off Power to Your Water Heater Properly disconnecting power is the most critical safety step in element replacement. Locate your home's electrical panel and switch off the circuit breaker labeled for the water heater, which is typically a 30-amp double-pole breaker. After turning off the breaker, verify power is truly off by using a non-contact voltage tester at the water heater's electrical junction box or thermostat wires. For additional safety, consider placing a piece of tape over the breaker or a note indicating that work is being performed on the circuit. Never rely solely on turning the water heater's thermostat to the "Off" position, as this does not disconnect power from the appliance. If your water heater has a disconnect box nearby (common in newer installations), turn this off as well for redundant protection. Wait 10-15 minutes after power disconnection before proceeding to allow any residual heat in the elements to dissipate. How to Drain the Hot Water Tank You have two draining options: partial draining (faster) or complete draining (better for maintenance). For partial draining: Drain only until the water level falls below the element location Upper elements require draining about 1/3 of the tank Lower elements require draining about 2/3 of the tank For complete draining (recommended if tank is due for maintenance): Allow all water to exit the tank This provides opportunity to flush out sediment Takes longer but improves heater efficiency The draining process: Connect a garden hose to the drain valve at the tank bottom Route the hose to a drain or outside location that can handle hot water Open a hot water faucet in the house to prevent vacuum formation Open the drain valve slowly to begin water flow Allow water to drain until desired level is reached For stubborn drain valves, a flathead screwdriver may help open the valve Caution: The draining water will be hot and can cause burns – begin draining with care. How to Remove the Old Heating Element The removal technique varies slightly depending on whether you have screw-in or flange-type elements. For standard screw-in elements (most common): Remove the access panel cover, typically secured with screws Pull back the insulation to expose the element and thermostat Take a photo of the wire connections for reference Use a screwdriver to remove wires from the element terminals Insert an element wrench over the element base Turn counterclockwise with steady pressure to loosen Once loose, unscrew the element by hand and remove For flange-type elements: Remove the four bolts securing the element flange to the tank Carefully pull the element straight out to avoid damaging the opening If the element is stuck due to corrosion or mineral buildup: Apply penetrating oil to the threads and wait 15 minutes Try alternating between clockwise and counterclockwise motions Tap gently around the perimeter with a hammer to break corrosion As a last resort, an element extraction socket can cut through damaged elements Inspect the removed element for signs of failure such as breaks, blistering, or heavy scale buildup. How to Install the New Heating Element Proper installation ensures leak-free operation and optimal heating performance. For screw-in elements: Inspect the tank opening for debris or scale and clean if necessary Place the new rubber gasket on the element (some elements have pre-installed gaskets) Apply a small amount of plumber's grease to the gasket if desired (helps prevent sticking) Insert the element and hand-tighten clockwise Use the element wrench to tighten until snug (approximately 1/2 to 3/4 turn past hand-tight) Avoid overtightening, which can damage the gasket or tank threads For flange-type elements: Position the new element with gasket against the tank opening Insert and hand-tighten all four bolts in a diagonal pattern Use a wrench to tighten the bolts evenly, working in a star pattern Tighten until the gasket is compressed but not crushed Reconnect the electrical wires to the appropriate terminals, ensuring they match the original configuration. Secure the connections tightly to prevent arcing or high-resistance connections that could cause overheating. What Type of Replacement Element Do You Need? Selecting the correct replacement element is crucial for proper function and safety. First, determine whether you need an upper or lower element for dual-element heaters (they often have different wattage ratings). Check the voltage requirement – most residential water heaters use 240V elements, but some use 120V. Identify the wattage rating, typically between 1,500 and 5,500 watts, which should match your original element. Measure the element length and thread size to ensure proper fit (common sizes are 1", 1-1/4", and 1-1/2"). Choose between screw-in (most common) or flange-type elements based on your existing installation. Select the element material: Copper: Less expensive but prone to lime buildup Stainless steel: More expensive but resists lime buildup and lasts longer Nickel-plated copper: Middle option for moderate water conditions Low-density elements (longer, folded design) work better in hard water areas as they operate at lower surface temperatures. High-density elements (shorter, more compact) heat water faster but are more susceptible to failure in hard water. The information needed is typically found on the old element or the water heater's data plate. How Much Does a Water Heater Element Cost? Water heater element costs vary based on type, quality, and where you purchase them. Element TypeBasic ModelPremium ModelFeatures of PremiumStandard Screw-in$15-$25$30-$50Longer life, scale-resistantLow-Density$20-$30$35-$60Better for hard waterFlange-Type$25-$40$45-$75Improved gaskets, corrosion resistanceSmart Element$50-$80$90-$150Digital controls, energy management Professional installation costs typically range from $150-$300, depending on: Local labor rates Accessibility of the water heater Whether tank draining/refilling is included If additional repairs are needed DIY replacement costs only the price of the element and basic supplies (approximately $20-$30 for Teflon tape, gasket, etc.). Many home improvement stores offer budget elements that work adequately, while plumbing supply stores typically carry higher-quality options with better warranties. Common Mistakes When Replacing Water Heater Elements Avoid these frequent errors to ensure a successful element replacement: Not turning off power at the circuit breaker (creating shock hazard) Failing to verify power is off with a voltage tester Installing an element with incorrect voltage or wattage rating Overtightening the element, which can damage threads or crack the tank Not using a new gasket with the replacement element Forgetting to refill the tank before restoring power Using the wrong type of element for your water conditions Improper wire connections or loose terminals Failing to check for leaks before completing the job Not addressing sediment buildup while the tank is drained Using plumber's tape on the element threads (use only on pipe connections) Replacing just one element when both are old in a dual-element system Turning power on before the tank is completely full Not opening faucets to release air during refilling Careful attention to these details prevents damage to your water heater and ensures safe, effective operation. Should You Replace Both Elements at the Same Time? For dual-element water heaters, replacing both elements simultaneously offers several advantages. If one element has failed due to age, the second element is likely nearing the end of its useful life as well. Replacing both elements: Ensures balanced heating performance Prevents a second service interruption in the near future Takes advantage of the tank already being drained Provides consistent heating capacity Often costs only $15-$25 more in parts Situations where replacing only one element makes sense: When one element is significantly newer than the other If budget constraints are severe When diagnostic testing confirms only one element is faulty If the failed element was damaged by an external factor (power surge, etc.) For water heaters over 8 years old, replacing both elements is particularly recommended as preventative maintenance. The labor involved in accessing and replacing both elements is minimal once the tank is already drained. How to Test if Your Water Heater Element is Bad Before Replacing It Turn off power to the water heater at the circuit breaker. Remove the access panel and insulation to expose the element and thermostat. Disconnect one wire from the element terminal to isolate it from the circuit. Set a digital multimeter to measure resistance (ohms). Touch the multimeter probes to the two terminals on the heating element. For a good element, you should get a reading between 10-30 ohms (exact values vary by wattage). A reading of infinity (OL on digital meters) indicates an open element that needs replacement. Next, touch one probe to a terminal and one to the metal tank. A reading other than infinity indicates a ground fault in the element, requiring replacement. Repeat the process for the second element if you have a dual-element water heater. Reconnect any wires you disconnected after testing is complete. Replace any element that failed either test. This testing process helps confirm element failure before purchasing replacements and prevents unnecessary work. How Long Does it Take to Replace a Water Heater Element? The complete element replacement process typically takes 1-2 hours for a DIY homeowner. Time breakdown by task: Preparation and gathering tools: 10-15 minutes Shutting off power and verifying: 5 minutes Draining the tank (partial): 15-30 minutes Draining the tank (complete): 30-45 minutes Removing access panel and disconnecting wires: 5-10 minutes Removing old element: 5-15 minutes (longer if stuck) Installing new element: 5-10 minutes Refilling tank: 10-20 minutes Checking for leaks: 5 minutes Restoring power and confirming operation: 5 minutes Factors that can extend the timeline: Difficult access to the water heater Corroded or stuck elements requiring extra effort Complete tank draining and flushing First-time DIY experience Complications like stripped threads or damaged wiring Experienced DIYers or professionals can complete the job in under an hour with partial draining. Are There Different Types of Water Heater Elements? Water heater elements come in several designs, each with specific applications and benefits. Element TypeDesignBest ForLifespanCostScrew-inThreaded base that screws directly into tankMost residential heaters3-5 years$15-$50FlangeMounted with 4 bolts through a flangeCommercial and some residential4-6 years$25-$75CopperTraditional metal with high conductivitySoft water areas2-4 years$15-$30Stainless SteelCorrosion-resistant metalHard water areas5-7 years$25-$60Low-DensityLonger, folded design with more surface areaHard water regions4-6 years$20-$60High-DensityCompact, concentrated heating elementSoft water, faster recovery2-5 years$15-$40Lime-LifeSpecial coating to resist mineral buildupExtremely hard water5-8 years$30-$70 Element wattage typically ranges from 1,500 to 5,500 watts, with higher wattage providing faster heating but requiring appropriate electrical service. Dual-element heaters often use a non-simultaneous operation design where only one element operates at a time, controlled by the thermostats. The upper element typically receives priority, activating first to heat the top portion of the tank for faster hot water availability. Troubleshooting After Replacing a Water Heater Element Even with careful installation, issues can arise after element replacement. If you experience leaking around the element: Tighten the element slightly more (1/8 to 1/4 turn) If leaking persists, drain the tank and check the gasket for proper placement Consider replacing the gasket if it appears damaged or compressed If there's still no hot water after replacement: Verify power is restored at the circuit breaker Check that thermostats are properly set and functioning Ensure all electrical connections are secure Confirm both elements are working in dual-element systems If the circuit breaker trips after replacement: The element may be shorted to ground Wires might be crossed or touching metal components The new element could be defective There might be water in the electrical compartment If water isn't hot enough: Check thermostat settings (typically 120-125°F is recommended) Verify the correct wattage element was installed Consider that recovery time may be longer with lower wattage elements For unusual noises after replacement: Air might be trapped in the system (run hot water to purge) Sediment could be contacting the new element The element might not be properly tightened How Often Should Water Heater Elements Be Replaced? Water heater elements typically last 3-7 years depending on water conditions and usage patterns. Hard water areas with high mineral content may experience element failure as early as 2-3 years without water treatment. Preventative replacement every 5 years can prevent unexpected cold showers and potential water damage from leaks. Factors affecting element lifespan: Water hardness (calcium and magnesium content) Sediment buildup in the tank Frequency of water heater use Quality of the element Power quality (surges and fluctuations) Whether the tank is regularly flushed Signs it's time for preventative replacement: Decreasing hot water output Increasing recovery time Age of elements exceeding 5 years Visible corrosion on element terminals Recent treatment system changes Annual tank flushing can significantly extend element life by removing sediment that causes elements to overheat. Do You Need to Flush the Water Heater When Replacing an Element? Flushing your water heater during element replacement is highly recommended and provides multiple benefits. Since the tank is already partially or fully drained for element replacement, flushing requires minimal additional effort. The flushing process: With the element removed, open the cold water inlet valve Allow water to flow through the tank and out the drain for 3-5 minutes Watch for sediment chunks and discoloration to clear Close the drain valve when water runs clear Benefits of flushing during element replacement: Removes sediment that causes elements to overheat and fail Improves energy efficiency by up to 15% Extends the life of the new element Reduces noise from sediment movement Improves recovery time and heating performance Provides cleaner hot water In hard water areas, consider adding a water heater cleaner solution before flushing for better results. Annual flushing is recommended for maintenance, but element replacement provides a perfect opportunity to perform this task. People Also Ask: Can I replace a water heater element without draining the tank?Technically yes, using specialized tools like an element change tool that acts as a plug, but it's not recommended. This method risks electrical shock, water damage, and improper installation. Partial draining to just below the element level is a safer compromise that saves time while maintaining safety. How long does it take for hot water to return after replacing an element?Hot water typically returns within 1-2 hours after replacing an element and restoring power. Recovery time depends on the element wattage, tank size, and incoming water temperature. A 40-gallon tank with a 4500-watt element generally heats from cold to 120°F in about 1-1.5 hours. Should I replace the thermostat when replacing a water heater element?It's not always necessary, but replacing the thermostat simultaneously is often wise if your water heater is over 5 years old. Thermostats are inexpensive ($15-$30) and frequently fail around the same time as elements. If you're experiencing temperature regulation issues along with heating problems, replacing both components ensures a complete system refresh. What causes a water heater element to burn out?The most common causes of element failure are sediment buildup, hard water mineral accumulation, and power surges. Sediment creates hot spots that cause elements to overheat and eventually fail. Other factors include normal age-related wear, dry firing (powering without water covering the element), and excessive cycling from undersized tanks. How do I know if I need an upper or lower element replacement?In dual-element heaters, if you have some hot water but it runs out quickly, the lower element is likely faulty. If you have no hot water at all, the upper element is probably the problem since it activates first. Testing both elements with a multimeter is the most accurate way to determine which needs replacement, as symptoms can sometimes be misleading.

Recent Posts